A fairness opinion is frequently obtained by a majority owner of a company that is attempting to buy out the interests of minority shareholders. When and why should a board require an independent. These materials have been prepared by evercore group l. It is designed to objectively show that there are numbers and logic behind a boards decision and they were acting in good faith in executing a transaction. Fairness opinions and capital markets ecmi research report. Sample fairness opinion available from bvr business.
This was related to a perception of deserving and undeserving groups. Seventh circuit issues significant opinion affecting. A fairness opinion is an expression of a financial advisers opinion as to the fairness, from a financial point of view, of the financial terms of a corporate transaction. Classroom discussion questions, writing assignments, student activities, and tips for parents. Letter to board of directors fairness opinion us legal. The fcc eliminated the policy in 1987 and removed the rule that implemented the. Double click on the pdf and a separate page will open. The fairness opinion provider is typically engaged by the debtor to issue the opinion to the debtors board of directors, which is permitted to provide an informational copy to the credit agreement administrative agent, the bond indenture trustee, or both. Fairness opinion a valuation opinion important in mergers. Fairness is concerned with actions, processes, and consequences, that are morally right honorable, and equitable. Delawares framework for disclosing fairness opinions 883 the business combination is fair, i. Fairness opinion charles vogele sodali transactions.
A letter of intent covering some of the major terms and conditions of the. Weunderstandthatmetropolitanhealthcorporation,amichigannonprofitcorporation. At the outset, understand the legal framework for a fairness opinion assignment in the relevant jurisdiction. The business judgment rule and the entire fairness doctrine structurally, the business judgment rule has two components. Fairness opinion guide without kking marshall stevens. No other party with the exception of counsel in limited instances may rely on it, and the dissemination of the valuation is controlled by the esop trustee and is largely restricted. Fairness opinions in the context of recent delaware chancery.
Mar 03, 2017 for example, in chemtrade logistics inc. In many circumstances, the fairness opinion will only address the fairness of the consideration to be received by the selling shareholders. For example, the standard of value sometimes is fair market value, and sometimes it is not. This fairness opinion states that the transaction, in its entirety, is fair to the esop from a. The importance of fairness opinions in transactions the final aspect of many mergersale transactions is the fairness opinion. As a subscriber service, bvwire extracted this sample houlihan lokey fairness opinion, typical of the longer form fairness opinion, from the sec edgar database.
For the complete presentation on fairness opinions click here. The first component immunizes directors from personal liability if they act in accordance with its requirements while the second component insulates the court from intervening in management decisions made by the directors. We will receive a fee for our services pursuant to the engagement letter, which will. The terms of these highrisk transactions are likely to be heavily scrutinized by various stakeholders with diverse interests and rights. They are typically issued when a public company is being sold, merged or divested of all or a substantial division of their business. A fairness opinion is just a detailed valuation of a company thats being. A fairness opinion is a report that evaluates the facts of a merger, acquisition, carve out, spinoff, buyback or another type of purchase and. Fairness is when everyone is treated equally and no one is left out.
Neither canexus nor its two financial advisors disclosed the detailed financial analysis underlying the opinions. A fairness opinion is provided by an independent financial advisor to the board of directors of selling companies in many transactions today, especially those with a significant number of minority shareholders. A fairness opinion constitutes the formal written opin ion of a valuation professional given to the body for example, the board or a special committee making. Letter to board of directors fairness opinion us legal forms. What are investment banking fairness opinions, and why do banks provide them. This sample form, a detailed letter to board of directors fairness opinion document, is a model for use in corporate matters. Sec approves fairness opinion proposal october 17, 2007.
History and constitutional issues congressional research service summary the fairness doctrine was a policy of the federal communications commission fcc or commission that required broadcast licensees to cover issues of public importance and to do so in a fair manner. A fairness opinion is a professional evaluation by an investment bank or other third party as to whether the terms of a merger, acquisition, buyback, spinoff, or privatization are fair. This opinion gives the board of directors of the selling entity a defense in case it is later sued by investors for n. Evercore for the special committee of the board of directors the special committee of. Finding actual fairness opinions is not the easiest thing in the world, so here are links to good examples. An independent opinion characterizing the fair value of a firms stock. The sec has finally approved the rule 2290 fairness opinion proposal originally made in 2005 by the nasd now finra, which will require member firms to comply with certain disclosure and procedural requirements in rendering fairness opinions. Key factors to think about as you go into a fairness opinion. Seventh circuit issues significant opinion affecting fairness opinion practice by charles baker and karoline hinga on february 20, 2008, the seventh circuit issued an opinion in a case called ha 2003 liquidating trust v. Questions about the utility of fairness opinions have periodically seized headlines for many years. The opinion relates to the price offered by the buyer and the fairness of the terms to the companys shareholders. The longer opinion will typically state quite clearly what it is not. The fairness opinion serves as a basis to assess the financial adequacy of sempione retails offer. When and why should a board require an independent fairness.
As the acquisition of esopassociated businesses becomes more popular among middle market pe firms, the understanding and use of fairness opinions is more critical. A fairness opinion is a detailed analysis of a purchase offer by a valuation firm or investment bank, stating its belief that an offer made to acquire a target company is fair. We describe how courts should scrutinize the definition of fair price, the measurement of fair price. When and why should a board require an independent fairness opinion. Esop employer stock purchase transaction fairness opinions. People that are fair follow the rules in sports, games, activities, and in their community. Fairness definition and meaning collins english dictionary. In essence, the virtue of fairness establishes moral standards for decisions that affect others. A fairness opinion simply states that a proposed transaction is fair from a financial point of view.
Required fairness opinion procedures new rule 2290b requires the member to have written procedures for approval of a fairness opinion including the following. When to use fairness opinions in private transactions. Dictionary grammar blog school scrabble thesaurus translator quiz more resources more from collins. Credit suisse did not withdraw its opinion the transaction closed and buyer went bankrupt a year later as the tech bubble imploded. Bdo usa, llp, a delaware limited liability partnership, is the u. Some of these are quite old, but corporate valuation barely changes over time so they are equally valid today.
This fairness opinion goes beyond the price per share or the value of the stock being purchased. The business judgment rule and the entire fairness doctrine. Opinion what monkeys can teach us about fairness the. They offer protection for shareholders and can be imperative in hostile takeovers and distress sales. Its been a couple of weeks since i last finished a chapter in michael sandels book, what money cant buy. If the fairness opinion contains useful information to investors, then one would expect, for example, the acquirers stock price to go up when the targets own fairness opinion suggests a relatively high value. A representation letter, dated september 11, 2019, has been submitted to us by the client stating that all information, which is relevant to the. The fairness opinion intends to give charles vogeles board of directors and public shareholders a neutral opinion and assure that the offered price per share is fair and reasonable from a financial. A fairness opinion can help demonstrate that fiduciary duty was executed in good faith and can reduce the chance of shareholder dispute resulting from the transaction. Fairness is defined as just and reasonable treatment in accordance with accepted rules or principles. Building understanding of fairness, equality and good relations vi there was a view that britain can be too fair.
It is from the linkedin sale to microsoft produced by qatalyst partners. Credit suisse fairness opinion for lbo of sungard data systems. They offer protection for shareholders and can be imperative in hostile takeovers and distress sales fairness opinions address the fairness of the purchase price in an anticipated. The importance of fairness opinions in transactions mercer. In connection with an acquisition, merger, membership substitution, or other combination, a fairness opinion is an opinion. If we did not have fairness our lives would be crazy. As the leading fairness opinion advisor, we can readily speak to the value of the opinions we provide and the best practices we observe in rendering them. The fairness doctrine of the united states federal communications commission fcc, introduced in 1949, was a policy that required the holders of broadcast licenses to both present controversial issues of public importance and to do so in a manner that wasin the fccs viewhonest, equitable, and balanced. It is from the linkedin sale to microsoft produced by. A fairness opinion is a report compiled by a qualified investment banker or advisor that evaluates the fairness of the price offered during an acquisition, takeover, or merger. Outside of investment banks, some big 4 firms also do fairness opinion work and dedicated valuation boutiques also issue opinions from time to time. Because a fairness opinion is, by definition, an opinion, courts have held that it will be deemed a false statement for the purposes of the federal securities laws only if it is objectively and subjectively false. Fairness opinion re equity value of option nv we enclose our fairness opinion report on the equity value of option nv as at 31 december 2017 in accordance with the terms of the engagement letter dated october 2017. Fairness opinions are filled with sec and stored in the edgar database which is available to the public.
Elementary school k5 teaching guide discussion guide, lesson plan, teachers guide for fairness and justice. Building understanding of fairness, equality and good relations. I recently completed chapter 3 a couple of nights ago and there were some intriguing things to think about. This article discusses fairness opinions in affiliated party transactions and focuses on the following topics. Indeed, obtaining a fairness opinion is a best practice when considering a wide range of transactions, including minority redemptions, recapitalization, combinations and spinoffs, just to name a few.
Building understanding of fairness, equality and good. A fairness opinion, by definition, is a letter prepared by an experienced investment banker or business appraiser, which states whether or not a transaction from a. A fairness opinion provides important information in a variety of financial transactions, such as. The valuation and fairness opinion performed by the esop trustee financial advisor is for the exclusive use of the esop trustee. A fairness opinion can help the board or a special committee of the board determine whether a proposed transaction is fair to relevant stakeholders. A fairness opinion is a report that evaluates the facts of a merger, acquisition, carve out, spinoff, buyback or another type of purchase and provides an opinion as to whether. The purpose of the fairness opinion is to provide selling shareholders with an objective thirdparty analysis of the deals fairness. Fairness opinions in mergers and acquisitions anil k. The language is easily adapted to fit your specific circumstances. Fairness definition of fairness by the free dictionary. This opinion letter is subsequently included as an exhibit to the relevant statements filed with the sec in conjunction with the proposed transaction.
Unfortunately, too often, fiduciaries associate fairness opinions with acquisitions of large, public companies. May 10, 2016 the fairness opinion provider is typically engaged by the debtor to issue the opinion to the debtors board of directors, which is permitted to provide an informational copy to the credit agreement administrative agent, the bond indenture trustee, or both. Pdf fairness opinions in affiliated party transactions. Fairness opinion financial definition of fairness opinion.
Fair decisions are made in an appropriate manner based on appropriate criteria. Participants with this view felt some people get more out of the system than they put in. For example, there are some states in which attorneys general require a fairness opinion by a thirdparty valuation firm, investment banking firm, or other approved provider of similar services. Fairness opinion discussion materials prepared by evercore. Typically, fairness opinions for public companies will cost more than private companies because there are usually more shareholders. This memorandum is confidential to the management or shareholders of option nv. We have been engaged by the special committee of independent directors pursuant to an engagement letter dated june 14, 2005 the engagement letter to render a fairness opinion to the board of directors of the company in connection with the transaction. The delaware courts have decided many cases involving claims that some ele. Jun 14, 2016 so whats the actual cost of fairness and solvency opinions.
56 1322 208 731 1202 1416 692 463 225 906 807 1315 757 1114 1087 646 1524 690 1054 710 847 702 1155 1245 1453 483 848 1102